Home › Compare schedules › Which is best
Which shift schedule is best?
There is no answer to that question, and anyone who gives you one is selling something. Almost every 24/7 rotation lands within a few hours of the same weekly total. What separates them is which thing they protect — and you have to decide what you are protecting first.
Start with what you are optimising for
Pick the row below that describes what matters most in your life right now. The patterns underneath it are the ones that actually deliver it. Most of them can be found on the same department, so this is usually a bidding decision rather than a career one.
You want your weekends back
Only a cycle that divides evenly into seven can protect the same days forever. Fourteen-day patterns do; eight, nine and fifteen-day patterns never will.
You want long blocks of time off
For travel, a course, a second job, or anything that needs more than a long weekend.
You want to protect your sleep
A body clock that never resets beats every trick a rotation can use. Failing that, stay on one tour as long as possible and rotate forward, not backward.
You want fewer days at work
Same full-time job, fewer commutes, fewer briefings, fewer days out of your life.
You want more hours in your check
Some patterns are built above forty hours and some below. Before you argue for a change, know which side of forty yours sits on.
You want a schedule you can plan a life around
Predictability beats almost everything else once there are other people involved.
You are getting tired of long shifts
Twelve-hour shifts get harder with time, and the last two hours are where it shows.
Three things that are true of all of them
Most 24/7 rotations average about forty-two hours a week. Panama, Pitman, DuPont, Continental, Southern Swing, 4 on 4 off, 3 on 3 off and 7 on 7 off all land there. If someone tells you their schedule is easier because of the hours, check — it is usually the shape, not the total.
A cycle that does not divide into seven will take your weekends. Six, eight, nine and fifteen-day cycles all walk through the week forever. That is not a flaw, it is arithmetic, and no amount of bidding fixes it.
The schedule on paper is not the schedule you work. Court, overtime, callbacks, training and paid duty jobs land on top of every pattern here, and they are what actually fill your days off.
The honest summary
If you can hold a fixed tour and your life has other people in it, take the fixed tour. If you want time in blocks and can absorb long runs, take a twelve-hour rotation with a long break. If you are tired at the end of shifts, go shorter before you go longer.
And whichever you work, the part worth tracking is not the rotation — it is everything that lands on top of it.
The shift schedule you actually work
Your rotation, your paid duty work, one calendar.
Scan to install — or hold it up for the officer next to you.
